• Home
  • Our SOS
    • Save Our Military Remains & Shipwrecks
    • Save Our Sealife
    • Save Our Shore
  • The Campaign
    • Marine Conservation Zones Consultation 2018
    • Public Consultation 2017 (now closed)
    • Responses to the 2017 Public Consultation
    • Downloads
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Get Involved
    • Sign the Petition
    • Make a Donation
  • Latest News
    • All News
    • Sign up for Updates
  • Our Support
    • Notable Supporters
    • Supporting Organisations
  • Campaign Team
  • Contact

Save our Goodwin Sands from dredging by Dover Harbour Board

goodwinsandssos@gmail.com
Goodwin Sands SOSGoodwin Sands SOS
  • Home
  • Our SOS
    • Save Our Military Remains & Shipwrecks
    • Save Our Sealife
    • Save Our Shore
  • The Campaign
    • Marine Conservation Zones Consultation 2018
    • Public Consultation 2017 (now closed)
    • Responses to the 2017 Public Consultation
    • Downloads
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Get Involved
    • Sign the Petition
    • Make a Donation
  • Latest News
    • All News
    • Sign up for Updates
  • Our Support
    • Notable Supporters
    • Supporting Organisations
  • Campaign Team
  • Contact

Judicial Review Granted for Dredging Decision

March 9, 2019 News 2 Comments

GOODWIN SAND SOS PRESS RELEASE SATURDAY MARCH 9TH 2019

We won a significant battle at the High Court yesterday, when claimant Joanna Thomson was awarded a Judicial Review of the Marine Management Organisation’s decision to allow Dover Harbour Board to dredge 3 million tonnes of aggregate from the South Goodwins sandbank.

Outside the Royal Courts of Justice – from L-R: Daniel Piccinin of Brick Court Chambers, Mrs Joanna Thomson, Paul Taylor of Richard Buxton Ltd (solicitors)

The Judge, The Honourable Mrs Justice Thornton granted Joanna’s solicitors leave to proceed to a Judicial Review on one of the two grounds presented to the court by Marie Demetriou QC of Brick Court Chambers, London.

Leave was granted on account of the fact that the MMO had not considered the impact of the physical removal of the volume of 2 million m3 of sand from a designated Protected Feature within the Goodwin Sands proposed Marine Conservation Zone.  They had only considered the impact of removing the surface area of the subtidal sand, which is a designated Protected Feature within the proposed Marine Conservation Zone.

Leave was refused for the second ground, that the MMO could not conclude that dredging would pose no risk to the underwater cultural heritage of the Goodwin Sands  because the relevant document had not been agreed and finalised before making their decision.  Joanna’s, Richard Buxton Ltd, are considering appealing against this ruling.

Richard Kerr-Wilson, whose uncle Flying Officer Jack Kerr Wilson (no hyphen on purpose) was shot down over the Goodwins in May 1940, welcomed the decision, saying that ‘the Goodwins should be respected as a war grave for those who gave their lives for their country during WWII’.

After the hearing, Joanna stated ‘this is a major step forward for all of us who consider the Goodwin Sands should not be subject to rapacious mining by Dover Harbour Board, or anyone else.  They are quite simply, not a quarry to be exploited by a budget driven developer trying to get away with applying 1980’s lack of regulations to the present day requirements of detailed Environmental Statements’. 

The Sands, which are a proposed Marine Conservation Zone, have been described by Wessex Archaeology, who reviewed data for Dover Harbour Board’s environmental consultants, as ‘archaeologically extraordinary’ on account of their holding the highest density of maritime assets in UK waters.

Judge Justine Thornton overturned a previous ruling by Judge David Holgate, who initially refused leave to proceed, in what could only be described as ‘a vitriolic rant from someone who had clearly not read the papers properly’.

It is anticipated that the Judicial Review will be held in June and will take place at the High Court.  Dover Harbour Board requested that the hearing took place before 21st June  2019 and this was accepted by both the Judge and Joanna’s Counsel.  The costs cap against Joanna in case she loses was capped at £10K but Richard Buxton wants to appeal this also as it is based entirely on the expectation of being able to raise more funds.

A transcript of Judge Thornton’s summing up will be made available in due course.

END


BBC Radio 4 News – 8th March 2019

BBC Radio 4 News – 8th March 2019

More Funds are now Needed

This is of course excellent news but we now need to raise at least another £30K for legal fees going forward.  We have already raised this amount so we know it can be done!  Donations can be made through our CrowdJustice link, or if you are a UK taxpayer, please contact us direct, again through the website, as we can claim gift aid, which would boost your donation by 20%.

Pledge to our CrowdJustice campaign

2 Comments
Share
1

You also might be interested in

Goodwin Sands Judicial Review has been dismissed

Goodwin Sands Judicial Review has been dismissed

Sep 10, 2019

The Honourable Sir Duncan Ouseley has dismissed Goodwin Sands SOS[...]

Dunkirk star Sir Mark Rylance launches fresh attack on dredging plans
Mark Rylance who won an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in 'Bridge of Spies' and recently appeared in 'Dunkirk' - Photo by Georges Biard [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Dunkirk star Sir Mark Rylance launches fresh attack on dredging plans

Aug 6, 2017

Sir Mark Rylance, star of the recent film ‘Dunkirk’ has[...]

Battle of Goodwin Sands: Fury over plan to dredge sandbank where remains of RAF heroes have laid for 76 years

Battle of Goodwin Sands: Fury over plan to dredge sandbank where remains of RAF heroes have laid for 76 years

Sep 28, 2016

Daily Mail, 28th September 2016 For 76 years it has[...]

2 Comments

Leave your reply.
  • jules palliser
    · Reply

    March 9, 2019 at 5:21 PM

    Well done Joanna! I think we’re going to win!!

  • Mary Bassendine
    · Reply

    March 11, 2019 at 9:02 PM

    Hurrah!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign the Petition

Sign the Petition


Recent Posts

  • Goodwin Sands Conservation Trust website
  • VE75
  • East Kent seafront resident’s concerns for coastal erosion and future dredging plans
  • Messages from Dover & Deal prospective parliamentary candidates
  • Goodwin Sands Judicial Review has been dismissed

Recent Comments

  • Mauro Feltrin on Messages from Dover & Deal prospective parliamentary candidates
  • Mary Bassendine on Judicial Review Granted for Dredging Decision
  • jules palliser on Judicial Review Granted for Dredging Decision
  • Joanna Thomson on Possible WWII bomber discovered on the Goodwin Sands
  • Pauline Terry on Sir Tim Smit KBE speaks out against the rapacious mining of the Goodwin Sands

Archives

  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • September 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • February 2018
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • May 2016

Contact Us

We're currently offline. Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message
Goodwin Sands SOS

Save our Goodwin Sands
from dredging

#SaveOurSands

Contact Information

  • Goodwin Sands SOS
  • goodwinsandssos@gmail.com
  • goodwinsandssos.org

Twitter Feed

Tweets by @@GoodwinSandsSOS

© 2023 · Goodwin Sands SOS

  • Home
  • The Campaign
  • Sign the Petition
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Prev Next
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead our Privacy Policy